By Ramón Mercader
kites-journal.org
1 April 2024
At a press conference yesterday, Republican State Senator Chad Whitesmart said he felt confident that his bill before the Florida state legislature, the Protecting the Unborn Children of All Birthing People Act, would pass without much opposition. Whitesmart explained that “the genius of this total abortion ban is its use of inclusive language. It makes clear that abortion won’t just be banned for women, but also for any trans and nonbinary people who can give birth.” In a tactical move that sharply contrasts with Florida’s Governor DeSantis, Whitesmart even requested that members of the Florida state legislature state their preferred gender pronouns before voting on the bill. Whitesmart explained that “I’ve watched these leftist organizations do the whole pronoun circle thing at the beginning of their meetings and then fail to defend the rights of trans people when politicians like me take them away, so I figured doing a pronoun circle in the Florida state legislature could only help my agenda.”
Notably, while most abortion bans have passed along partisan lines in red states, Whitesmart’s bill managed to receive the support of a number of Democrats, especially younger, more woke ones. In fact, some abortion rights groups decided not to protest the bill. In a statement on Instagram, the intersectional, socialist-feminist collective NYC for Abortion Rights explained that “while we oppose abortion bans, inclusivity of language is far more important to us than women’s reproductive rights. Given that Whitesmart’s bill uses inclusive language, we cannot, in good conscience, oppose it. If it had been titled Protecting the Unborn Children of Women, we surely would have, but since it uses the word birthing people instead of women, we have to let this one slide.” Sherry Wolf, formerly of the International Socialist Organization and then part of NYC for Abortion Rights, further clarified that they consider it more important to oppose political organizations that use the word “women” while protesting for abortion rights than to oppose abortion bans themselves.


